Irshad Manji wrote a column for the WSJ’s Opinion Journal about Muslims in America and Europe:
Against the backdrop of civil war, Abraham Lincoln stirred Americans by appealing to their “better angels.” Now some of those angels appear in an unprecedented study about Muslims in the United States–and they may show us how to prevent civil war in Europe.
“Muslim Americans,” released by the Pew Research Center, contains moments of bad news. For example, one in four respondents under the age of 30 accepts suicide bombing. As a reformed-minded Muslim, I say that honoring any religion of peace through violence is like preserving virginity through pre-marital sex. Think about it.
But the Pew report offers a lot more good news. Political Islam has not caught on in America as it has in Europe because most Muslims in the U.S. are–dare it be said–treated with dignity.
The vast majority of those surveyed like their communities and describe their lives as “pretty happy” or “very happy.” Which means lobbyists do not speak for Muslim Americans when they cry that the U.S. hates Islam.
Nice. So this means that, according to Manji, Europe doesn’t treat its Muslim population with dignity and that is the reason why quite some Muslim immigrants aren’t assimilated well.
If only we’d treat them with more dignity! Shame on us.
Well, luckily, Manji realizes that there is much more to it than that: for instance, many immigrants refuse to speak the language of their new country.
Yes, there is also racism, but I find that most immigrants use racism as an excuse. The racism is, by no means, so bad as to become an extremist because of it. The far majority of Europeans do not discriminate.
Discrimination is a problem, we have to fight it, but lets not pretend that if only the discrimination goes away, all will be fine.
Personally I believe that there is one major difference between the US and Europe which explains why US immigrants assimilate better: when immigrants come here, they suddenly are taken care off by the government. They can get welfare, they can get financial help. In short, there is less need for them to learn the language and work hard. In America, if you’re an immigrant and you don’t work you starve to death (as a figure of speech). If you’re an immigrant in Europe and you don’t work, you get money from the government.
So, we need to change that, we need to adopt America’s system. This has to be combined with a broad effort to combat racism of course. We should demand of our immigrants that they work for a living, and they should be able to demand that if they do, that if they are willing to work hard, they will not fail because of racism / discrimination. As Manji writes:
Translation: A common aspiration such as the American Dream is crucial to giving Muslims a sense of belonging to something larger and more dynamic than cultural enclaves.
h/t Holly