An interesting column, by E.J. Dionne Jr., appeared in today’s Washington Post. Mr. Dionne writes:
“Let’s grow up, conservatives!”
Barry M. Goldwater’s declaration at the 1960 Republican National Convention was designed to quell a rebellion against Richard M. Nixon, whom conservatives saw as selling out to liberals on various platform planks. Goldwater’s next line was uncannily prophetic: “If we want to take this party back, and I think we can someday, let’s get to work.” Forty-seven years later, the conservatives whose cause Goldwater championed still dominate the Republican Party.
The Democratic Party’s progressive wing, furious at what it sees as the capitulation of its congressional leaders to President Bush on the Iraq war, should remember this history. The decision to drop withdrawal timelines from the Iraq supplemental appropriations bill is not a decisive defeat. It is a temporary setback in a much longer struggle for minds and votes that the administration’s critics are actually winning…
Rep. Dave Obey (D-Wis.), chairman of the House Appropriations Committee, said recently that no one remembers how long it took to reverse the direction of American policy in Vietnam. Obey is hunkered down for a lengthy struggle.
In a divided system, democracy can be frustratingly slow. But it usually works. Critics of the war should spend less time mourning the setbacks of May and begin organizing for a showdown in September. They would profit from taking Barry Goldwater’s long view.
Irony at its finest: ‘liberals’ looking at Barry Goldwater for inspiration.
There is a lot of truth to what Dionne is saying though: the Democrats caved in this time, but that doesn’t mean that the progressive movement has lost or will lose in the end. If I were a member of the progressive movement, I would use this as a means to re-energize the base, I would look at the bigger picture (battles like this take years), I would reward those politicians who did what the progressive movement wanted, and I would try to put pressure on those who didn’t do what the pm wanted, as to make sure that they will do what it wants next time (coming September).
There is only one problem: I believe that Americans are, culturally, more conservative than progressive. Therefore, a conservative movement can be successful, whereas a progressive movement cannot, at least not in the truly long run. They might win some battles, but they won’t win the war, so to speak.